Can I Mix Sae 40 With 20W50 – 0 – The Definitive Answer For DIY
You can mix SAE 40 with 20W-50 oil in an emergency to top off a low engine, but it should not be a long-term solution. Doing so will alter the final viscosity and compromise the oil’s performance, especially its ability to protect your engine during cold starts. After mixing, plan for a full oil change as soon as possible.
You’re halfway through a road trip, or maybe just on your way home from work, when the dreaded oil light flickers on. You pull over, check the dipstick, and sure enough, it’s low. You find an old bottle of SAE 40 in your trunk, but your engine calls for 20W-50. The panic sets in: can I mix SAE 40 with 20W-50 just to get by?
This is a situation almost every car owner, DIYer, and rider has faced. The answer isn’t a simple yes or no; it’s about understanding what you’re putting in your engine and the potential consequences. Making the wrong choice could risk engine health, while the right one can get you safely to your destination.
In this complete guide, we’ll dive deep into the science behind these oil weights, the real-world impact of mixing them, and the best practices to follow. You’ll learn exactly when it’s acceptable, what problems to watch for, and how to handle the situation like a seasoned pro.
Understanding Oil Viscosity: What Do SAE 40 and 20W-50 Really Mean?
Before we can talk about mixing, we need to get on the same page about what these numbers on the bottle actually represent. They all relate to viscosity—a fluid’s resistance to flow. Think of it like the difference between pouring water (low viscosity) and honey (high viscosity).
Your engine needs an oil that’s thin enough to flow quickly when cold but thick enough to protect moving parts when it’s at operating temperature. This is where the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) ratings come in.
Decoding SAE 40: The Monograde Workhorse
SAE 40 is a monograde oil. This means it has a single viscosity rating that was tested at a high operating temperature (212°F or 100°C). It doesn’t have a separate rating for cold-weather performance.
You’ll typically find SAE 40 used in:
- Older, classic car engines designed before multi-grade oils were common.
- Small air-cooled engines like those in lawnmowers and generators.
- Some high-performance or racing applications in consistently hot climates.
The main drawback of a monograde oil is its lack of versatility. In cold weather, SAE 40 can become very thick, like molasses, making it difficult for the oil pump to circulate it during a cold start. This is a critical moment when most engine wear occurs.
Decoding 20W-50: The Versatile Multi-Grade
20W-50 is a multi-grade oil, and it’s the standard for many modern and classic vehicles, especially those that run hot or are under heavy load. The “W” stands for “Winter,” and it tells you how the oil flows at cold temperatures.
Here’s the breakdown:
- 20W: This is the cold-weather viscosity rating. A lower number means the oil flows better (is thinner) when cold. 20W provides good cold-start protection compared to a straight-weight oil like SAE 40.
- 50: This is the high-temperature viscosity rating, measured at the same operating temperature as the SAE 40. A 50-weight oil provides a thick, protective film for bearings and other critical parts under high heat and pressure.
Multi-grade oils achieve this magic using special polymers called Viscosity Index Improvers. These additives uncoil as the oil heats up, increasing its viscosity to maintain that protective film.
The Big Question: Can I Mix SAE 40 with 20W-50?
Now that we understand the difference, we can tackle the primary question. This is a crucial section of our can i mix sae 40 with 20w50 guide, so let’s get into the specifics.
The Short Answer: Yes, in a Pinch
If your engine is dangerously low on oil and all you have is a different-but-compatible grade, adding it is far better than running the engine on low oil. Starving your engine of oil can cause catastrophic failure within minutes.
Topping off with the wrong weight is a temporary fix to restore oil pressure and lubrication. Think of it as an emergency patch, not a permanent repair.
The Long Answer: What Happens When You Mix?
When you pour SAE 40 into an engine filled with 20W-50, you are fundamentally changing the oil’s formulation. The monograde SAE 40 will dilute the multi-grade 20W-50.
The final mixture will have a viscosity somewhere between the two, but it won’t be a predictable or stable new grade. More importantly, you are diluting the concentration of those critical Viscosity Index Improvers from the 20W-50. This means the oil’s ability to thicken up as it gets hot is reduced, and its ability to stay thin when cold is compromised.
Your “new” oil mix will behave more like a 20W-40 or something similar, but without the precise engineering of a purpose-blended oil.
Common Problems with Mixing SAE 40 and 20W-50 Long-Term
While a one-time top-off is manageable, making a habit of it or leaving the mixed oil in for a full service interval can lead to serious issues. Here are the most common problems with mixing SAE 40 and 20W-50.
Compromised Cold-Start Protection
The biggest risk is on cold mornings. The addition of the thicker SAE 40 means the oil won’t flow as quickly to the top of the engine upon startup. This brief period of reduced lubrication is when significant wear on cams, lifters, and bearings occurs.
Unpredictable High-Temperature Performance
If you have an engine that calls for a 50-weight oil (like an air-cooled Porsche, a Harley-Davidson, or a high-performance V8), it’s because it needs that thick oil film for protection under extreme heat. By diluting it with a 40-weight oil, you reduce that protective barrier, increasing the risk of metal-on-metal contact under heavy load or on a hot day.
Additive Package Imbalance
Modern oils are more than just base stock; they contain a carefully balanced package of additives. These include detergents to keep the engine clean, anti-wear agents like ZDDP, and corrosion inhibitors.
While most conventional oils from major brands are compatible, mixing them dilutes these packages. You might reduce the effectiveness of detergents or other crucial components, leading to increased sludge or wear over time.
Best Practices for Mixing Engine Oils: A Care Guide
If you find yourself in a position where you have to mix oils, don’t panic. Following a few simple rules can minimize any potential harm. This is your essential can i mix sae 40 with 20w50 care guide for handling the situation correctly.
Rule #1: The Emergency Top-Off Only
This cannot be stressed enough. Only mix oils to bring the level on your dipstick from dangerously low up to the “add” or “safe” mark. Use the smallest amount necessary. This is not a substitute for a proper oil change.
Rule #2: Change the Oil and Filter Sooner
Once you’ve mixed oils, your oil change clock has been reset. Don’t wait for your usual 3,000 or 5,000-mile interval. Plan to perform a full oil and filter change as soon as you reasonably can. This will flush out the compromised mixture and restore your engine’s protection with the correct grade of oil.
Rule #3: Match the API Service Category
Look for the “API Donut” on the back of the bottle. This seal indicates the oil’s performance standard (e.g., API SP, SN, or CJ-4 for diesels). As long as both oils meet the specification required by your vehicle’s manufacturer, their base chemistries are designed to be compatible, preventing any catastrophic reactions like gelling.
Sustainable and Eco-Friendly Considerations
When discussing oil, it’s important to touch on the environmental impact. The most sustainable can i mix sae 40 with 20w50 practice is to avoid it altogether. Using the correct oil specified for your engine ensures it runs as efficiently as possible, maximizing fuel economy and minimizing emissions.
Proper engine protection also extends the life of the engine itself, reducing the massive environmental cost associated with manufacturing a new vehicle or engine. An early oil change after an emergency mix is a small price to pay for long-term engine health.
Finally, whether your oil is mixed or not, always practice eco-friendly can i mix sae 40 with 20w50 disposal. Take your used oil to an auto parts store or a local recycling center. Never pour it down the drain or on the ground, as a single quart of oil can contaminate thousands of gallons of water.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mixing SAE 40 with 20W-50
What will the final viscosity be if I mix SAE 40 and 20W-50?
The final viscosity is not easily predictable and will not create a new, stable grade. It will be thicker than a 40-weight oil at operating temperature but thinner than a 50-weight. Its cold-flow properties will be worse than the original 20W-50.
Is it better to run low on oil or top off with the wrong kind?
It is always better to top off with the wrong (but compatible) oil. Running an engine low on oil can cause immediate and catastrophic damage from oil starvation. Topping off with a different grade is a temporary issue you can correct with an oil change.
Can I mix SAE 40 and 20W-50 in my motorcycle or lawnmower?
The same principles apply. Many air-cooled engines in motorcycles and outdoor power equipment call for these specific grades. While they are often more tolerant of slight viscosity changes, it’s still best to use the manufacturer’s recommended grade. An emergency top-off is acceptable, followed by a prompt oil change.
How much is too much to mix?
There’s no hard rule, but the less you add, the better. Adding one quart to a five-quart system is a 20% dilution, which is significant. Only add the minimum amount required to get the oil level back into the safe range on your dipstick.
In the end, knowing the answer to “can I mix SAE 40 with 20W-50” is about smart, situational decision-making. In an emergency, it’s a tool in your DIY toolkit to get you home safe. For long-term health, sticking to your manufacturer’s recommended oil grade is the undisputed champion of engine protection.
Keep the right bottle of oil in your garage, check your levels regularly, and you’ll be prepared for whatever the road throws at you. Happy wrenching!
- Gearbox Oil Grade 320 Viscosity – Unlocking Peak Performance And - December 15, 2025
- 30 Weight Gear Oil – The Essential Diyer’S Guide To Selection, - December 15, 2025
- Industrial Gear Oil Grades – Choosing The Right Lubricant For Peak - December 15, 2025