Can You Mix 5W40 With 10W40
In an emergency, you can mix 5W-40 and 10W-40 oil to top off your engine, provided they are the same type (e.g., synthetic with synthetic). However, this should only be a temporary solution, as it alters the oil’s viscosity and performance characteristics. Always plan for a full oil change with the correct grade as soon as possible.
You’re standing in the aisle of a gas station, staring at the wall of motor oils. Your dipstick just showed you’re a quart low, and your engine is the lifeblood of your vehicle. The problem? They don’t have the 5W-40 your car calls for, but there’s plenty of 10W-40.
This is a classic dilemma for any DIYer or road-tripper. The question, can you mix 5w40 with 10w40, isn’t just a simple yes or no. It’s about understanding what’s happening inside your engine when you do, and making the smartest choice for its long-term health.
In this guide, we’ll break down the science in simple terms, walk you through the real-world risks and benefits, and give you the confidence to handle this situation like a pro. We’ll cover everything from emergency top-offs to best practices for keeping your engine running smoothly for years to come.
Decoding the Numbers: What Do 5W-40 and 10W-40 Really Mean?
Before we can talk about mixing, we need to understand what we’re working with. Those numbers on the bottle aren’t just for decoration; they’re a grade standardized by the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) that tells you the oil’s viscosity, or its resistance to flow.
The “W” Number: Your Engine’s Cold-Start Friend
The first number followed by a “W” (which stands for “Winter”) indicates the oil’s viscosity at cold temperatures. The lower the number, the thinner the oil is when it’s cold, and the easier it flows.
- 5W oil flows better at colder temperatures than 10W oil.
- 10W oil is slightly thicker when cold.
This is crucial for engine protection during startups. A thinner oil like 5W-40 gets to critical engine components faster in freezing weather, reducing wear and tear on a cold engine.
The Second Number: High-Temperature Protection
The second number—in this case, ’40’ for both oils—represents the oil’s viscosity at normal engine operating temperatures (around 212°F or 100°C). Since both oils are a ’40’ weight at temperature, they provide a similar level of protection once your engine is warmed up.
So, the primary difference between 5W-40 and 10W-40 is their performance in the cold. This is the key factor to consider when contemplating mixing them.
So, Can You Mix 5W-40 with 10W-40? The Short and Long Answer
Now for the main event. The short answer is yes, you can mix them in a pinch. But the long answer is where the real expertise comes in, helping you avoid potential issues down the road.
The Emergency Top-Off: When It’s Generally Okay
Running your engine significantly low on oil is far more dangerous than topping it off with a slightly different viscosity. If you’re down a quart and 10W-40 is your only option for your 5W-40 engine, adding it is the right call.
A small amount of 10W-40 mixed into a larger volume of 5W-40 will only slightly change the overall viscosity. Your engine will barely notice the difference in the short term, especially in moderate or warm climates.
Why It’s Not a Long-Term Solution
Think of mixing oil viscosities like adding a bit of regular coffee to a decaf pot. You’ll end up with something in the middle, but it’s not what you originally intended. When you mix 5W-40 and 10W-40, you create a new blend with an unpredictable cold-weather viscosity—something like a “7.5W-40”.
This new blend won’t perform as well as pure 5W-40 in cold starts, potentially leading to increased engine wear over time. It’s a compromise, and not one you want to make permanent. Furthermore, some manufacturers may consider this a reason to void your warranty if engine problems arise.
The Golden Rule: Matching Oil Types is Non-Negotiable
Here’s a critical point: this entire discussion assumes you are mixing oils of the same type. You should always mix synthetic with synthetic, semi-synthetic with semi-synthetic, or conventional with conventional.
Modern oils are designed to be compatible, but their additive packages—the special chemicals that fight sludge, reduce friction, and prevent corrosion—are optimized for their specific base oil. Mixing a full synthetic with a conventional oil is asking for trouble and can compromise the performance of both.
Potential Benefits and Common Problems When You Mix 5W-40 with 10W-40
Let’s be clear: the only real “benefit” is avoiding catastrophic engine damage from running on low oil. But it’s important to understand the full picture, including the potential downsides. This is a core part of any good can you mix 5w40 with 10w40 guide.
The (Limited) Benefits: A Temporary Fix
- Prevents Oil Starvation: The number one benefit is getting oil back to a safe level, ensuring lubrication and preventing metal-on-metal contact.
- Maintains Oil Pressure: Topping off, even with a different grade, helps maintain proper oil pressure, which is vital for engine function.
Common Problems to Watch For
While a one-time top-off is unlikely to cause immediate damage, repeated mixing can lead to some common problems with can you mix 5w40 with 10w40. You might notice:
- Slightly Harder Cold Starts: In cold climates, the thicker 10W component can make the engine turn over a bit more slowly.
- Marginally Reduced Fuel Economy: Thicker oil can create slightly more drag within the engine, potentially impacting your MPG, though likely not enough for most drivers to notice.
- Unpredictable Additive Performance: While rare with modern API-certified oils, different brands have unique additive formulas. Consistently mixing them can dilute the effectiveness of these packages.
A Practical Guide: How to Safely Mix Oils in a Pinch
If you find yourself in a situation where mixing is your only option, follow these steps. This is a quick “how to” on the topic of how to can you mix 5w40 with 10w40 for a safe outcome.
- Confirm Your Engine’s Recommended Oil: First, double-check your owner’s manual or the oil cap. Make sure you know what your engine should have.
- Check Your Current Oil Level and Type: With the engine off and cool, pull the dipstick, wipe it, re-insert it, and pull it again. Note how low it is and confirm the type of oil currently in the engine (e.g., full synthetic).
- Choose the Closest Match: If you must mix, ensure the replacement oil is the same type (synthetic for synthetic) and meets the same API service rating (e.g., API SP).
- Add the “Wrong” Viscosity Oil Sparingly: Only add enough to bring the level up to the “full” mark on the dipstick. Don’t overfill! A funnel is your best friend here to prevent spills.
- Plan for a Proper Oil Change: This is the most important step. At your earliest convenience, schedule a full oil and filter change to get the correct, manufacturer-specified oil back into your engine.
Best Practices for Engine Health: The Pro’s Care Guide
Avoiding this situation altogether is the best strategy. Following these can you mix 5w40 with 10w40 best practices will keep your engine happy and your mind at ease.
Always Prioritize Your Owner’s Manual
The engineers who designed your engine specified a particular oil viscosity for a reason. They’ve tested it across a range of temperatures and conditions. Trust their recommendation above all else. It’s the cornerstone of any good can you mix 5w40 with 10w40 care guide.
Keep a Spare Quart of the Correct Oil
The easiest way to avoid this problem is to buy an extra quart of the correct oil during your oil change. Keep it secured in your trunk in a spill-proof bag. For off-roaders and long-distance travelers, this isn’t just a tip—it’s essential gear.
Understanding Your Climate’s Impact
Some owner’s manuals provide a chart of acceptable oil viscosities based on ambient temperature. It’s possible that both 5W-40 and 10W-40 are acceptable for your vehicle, but in different temperature ranges. If you live in a place with very hot summers and mild winters, a switch to 10W-40 might even be acceptable seasonally, but always check your manual first!
The Eco-Friendly Angle: Sustainable Oil Management Tips
Being a responsible vehicle owner also means being mindful of the environment. Integrating sustainable can you mix 5w40 with 10w40 practices is simple.
The most eco-friendly can you mix 5w40 with 10w40 approach is to avoid mixing in the first place. Using the correct oil ensures optimal engine performance and fuel efficiency, reducing your overall carbon footprint.
Forcing an early oil change because you used the wrong top-off oil creates unnecessary waste. When you do perform an oil change, always take the used oil and the old filter to a designated recycling center, like an auto parts store or a local municipal waste facility. Never pour it down the drain or on the ground.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mixing 5W-40 and 10W-40
What happens if I mix 5w40 and 10w40?
You create a new oil blend with a viscosity somewhere between the two, primarily affecting its cold-start performance. For a small top-off, the effect is minimal. For a larger mix, it will behave more like a thicker oil in the cold, but will still provide ’40’ weight protection at operating temperature.
Is it better to run low on oil or top off with a different viscosity?
It is always better to top off with a compatible but different viscosity oil than to run the engine significantly low. Oil starvation can cause catastrophic, immediate engine failure, while a slightly altered viscosity is a minor, temporary issue.
Can I mix different brands of 5w40 and 10w40 oil?
Yes, as long as both oils meet the API service standard specified in your owner’s manual (e.g., API SP) and are the same type (synthetic with synthetic). Certified oils are formulated to be compatible with one another.
Will mixing oils void my car’s warranty?
It can. If you have an engine-related warranty claim and the dealership finds you’ve been using an oil viscosity other than what’s specified in the owner’s manual, they may have grounds to deny the claim. This is why it’s crucial to treat mixing as a temporary fix and get the correct oil in as soon as possible.
Your Engine’s Health Is In Your Hands
So, the next time you’re faced with that wall of oil choices, you’ll know exactly what to do. Mixing 5W-40 and 10W-40 isn’t a disaster, but it’s a short-term patch, not a long-term strategy. Your engine is a marvel of engineering that deserves the precise protection the manufacturer intended.
By understanding what those numbers mean and prioritizing your owner’s manual, you’re taking the best possible care of your vehicle. Keep a spare quart on hand, check your oil regularly, and you’ll be ready for whatever the road throws at you.
Drive safe, stay prepared, and keep those engines running strong!
- Engine Oil Ow 20 – Engine Oil 0W-20 - December 16, 2025
- 0W40 Supercar Oil – The Ultimate Guide To High-Performance Engine - December 16, 2025
- Engine Oil 0W40 – The Ultimate Guide For Performance, Protection, And - December 16, 2025