Can You Mix 5W-50 And 5W-40? A Mechanic’S Guide To Safe Topping Off
In short, yes, you can mix 5W-50 and 5W-40 oil in an emergency, like a necessary top-off to get you home safely. However, it should only be a temporary solution, as mixing will alter the final viscosity and potentially dilute the effectiveness of the oil’s additive package.
You’re standing in your garage, dipstick in hand, and notice you’re a quart low. You grab your usual bottle of 5W-40, but it’s empty. A quick search of the shelf reveals a full jug of 5W-50 from your other vehicle. The question hits you immediately: can you mix 5w50 and 5w40 without causing a major headache?
It’s a common dilemma for any DIYer or enthusiast. You know using the wrong oil is bad, but running the engine low on oil is catastrophic. You need a clear, no-nonsense answer from someone who’s been there.
This guide will give you that answer. We’ll break down exactly what happens when these oils meet, the specific situations where it’s acceptable, and the potential risks you need to understand to protect your engine for the long haul.
Understanding the Numbers: What Do 5W-40 and 5W-50 Really Mean?
Before we dive into mixing, let’s quickly demystify those numbers on the bottle. Understanding them is the foundation of making smart decisions for your engine. This isn’t just theory; it’s the practical knowledge that separates a good DIY mechanic from a great one.
The “W” for Winter: Cold-Start Performance
The first number followed by a “W” (which stands for Winter) indicates the oil’s viscosity, or thickness, at cold temperatures. In our case, both 5W-40 and 5W-50 have a “5W” rating.
This means they both have the same flow characteristics when your engine is cold. A lower “W” number means the oil is thinner in the cold, allowing it to circulate quickly and protect vital engine components during those crucial first few seconds after you turn the key.
The Second Number: High-Temperature Protection
The second number (40 or 50) represents the oil’s viscosity at the engine’s normal operating temperature (around 212°F or 100°C). This is where our two oils differ.
- 5W-40 behaves like a 40-weight oil when hot. It offers excellent protection for most modern passenger cars, trucks, and motorcycles.
- 5W-50 behaves like a 50-weight oil when hot. This thicker oil provides a more robust protective film under extreme conditions, such as high-performance driving, towing heavy loads, or operating in very hot climates.
Think of it like this: the 5W-50 offers a thicker cushion of protection when the engine is working its hardest and generating the most heat.
The Big Question: So, Can You Mix 5W-50 and 5W-40 Oil?
Now we get to the heart of the matter. You’re low on 5W-40 and all you have is 5W-50. Here’s the practical, real-world answer based on sound mechanical principles and experience. This is the core of our can you mix 5w50 and 5w40 guide.
The Short Answer: Yes, for an Emergency Top-Off
For a small top-off (a quart or less in a five-quart system), mixing 5W-50 into an engine that calls for 5W-40 is generally safe. The most critical rule is to ensure both oils are the same type—mix synthetic with synthetic, or conventional with conventional.
Modern motor oils are formulated to be compatible. Adding a small amount of a slightly different viscosity is far better than letting your engine run with dangerously low oil levels, which can lead to friction, overheating, and catastrophic failure.
The Long-Term Reality: Why It’s Not a Best Practice
While it’s okay in a pinch, you shouldn’t make a habit of it. When you mix the two, you create a new, intermediate viscosity. You’re no longer running a true 5W-40 or a 5W-50; you’re running something in between, maybe a “5W-42” or “5W-43.”
Your engine’s manufacturer specified a particular viscosity for a reason. It was engineered with precise clearances and tolerances that rely on that specific oil weight for optimal lubrication, cooling, and fuel efficiency. Consistently running a custom blend, even one that’s close, is not part of that design and can lead to common problems with can you mix 5w50 and 5w40 down the line.
Real-World Scenarios: When Mixing Might (and Might Not) Make Sense
Let’s move from the garage to the real world. Here are a few common situations where this question comes up, and the best way to handle each one.
Scenario 1: The Roadside Top-Off
You’re on a road trip, and the “check oil” light flickers on. The only gas station for miles has 5W-50, but your car needs 5W-40. This is the perfect example of when to mix.
The Verdict: Absolutely do it. Add a quart of 5W-50 to get the oil level back into the safe zone on your dipstick. Then, when you get home, plan to perform a full oil change a little sooner than you normally would to get the correct, uniform viscosity back into your engine.
Scenario 2: The Track Day or Off-Road Adventure
Some performance enthusiasts and off-roaders wonder if they can add some 5W-50 to their 5W-40 to get a little extra high-temperature protection for a hard day on the trail or track. This is where we advise caution.
The Verdict: Don’t play home chemist. If you need the protection of a 50-weight oil, drain the 40-weight and fill it entirely with a high-quality 5W-50. Oil manufacturers spend millions on research to perfect their additive packages. Mixing them is just guesswork and you risk diluting the effectiveness of those crucial detergents and anti-wear agents.
Scenario 3: Using Up Old Bottles
You have half a bottle of 5W-40 and half a bottle of 5W-50 left over. It’s tempting to combine them for your next oil change to save money and reduce waste. This touches on the idea of a sustainable can you mix 5w50 and 5w40 approach.
The Verdict: Avoid this for your primary vehicle. While it seems eco-friendly, you’re compromising your engine’s protection for a few dollars. A better eco-friendly can you mix 5w50 and 5w40 practice is to take both partial bottles to your local auto parts store or municipal recycling center for proper disposal.
A Practical Care Guide: How to Mix 5W-50 and 5W-40 Safely (If You Must)
If you find yourself in a situation where you absolutely must mix, follow these steps to minimize any potential risk. Consider this your essential can you mix 5w50 and 5w40 care guide for emergencies.
- Confirm Oil Type: The most important rule. Ensure you are mixing full synthetic with full synthetic or a synthetic blend with another synthetic blend. Never mix a conventional oil with a full synthetic unless the bottle explicitly states it is compatible.
- Use the Smallest Amount Necessary: Don’t dump in the whole bottle if you only need half a quart. Use your dipstick as a guide. Add a little at a time, wait a minute for it to settle, and re-check the level until it’s in the safe range.
- Document It: Make a note of what you added and when. A simple sticky note in the glove box or a note in your phone’s maintenance log will remind you that your oil is a mixed grade.
- Plan for an Earlier Oil Change: Don’t run the mixed oil for a full service interval. Plan to change your oil and filter 1,000-2,000 miles earlier than usual to restore the manufacturer-specified protection.
Potential Risks and Common Problems with Mixing Oil Viscosities
While a one-time mix isn’t a disaster, it’s important to understand the potential downsides. Following can you mix 5w50 and 5w40 best practices means knowing the risks you’re taking, even if they are small.
Unpredictable Viscosity and Performance
As mentioned, you’re creating an unknown oil grade. This new viscosity might be slightly too thick at operating temperature, which could marginally reduce fuel economy and horsepower as the engine works harder to pump it. While likely unnoticeable to the driver, it’s not what the engineers intended.
Diluting the Additive Package
Every brand of oil has a unique recipe of additives: detergents to keep the engine clean, dispersants to suspend contaminants, and anti-wear agents to protect metal surfaces. When you mix oils, especially from different brands, you can dilute this carefully balanced formula, potentially reducing its overall effectiveness.
Potential Warranty Complications
For a vehicle that is still under warranty, this is a serious consideration. If you experience an engine failure and the manufacturer performs an oil analysis, they could deny your warranty claim if they discover you’ve been using a non-specified or mixed-viscosity oil.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mixing 5W-50 and 5W-40
What happens if I accidentally did a full oil change with 5W-50 instead of 5W-40?
For most modern engines in normal driving conditions, this isn’t a catastrophic error, but it’s not ideal. The thicker 5W-50 oil might cause a slight decrease in fuel efficiency and may not flow as optimally through very tight tolerances in some modern engines. The best course of action is to drain it and refill with the correct 5W-40 at your earliest convenience.
Is it better to run a quart low or top off with the wrong viscosity?
It is always better to top off with a compatible but slightly different viscosity oil than to run the engine significantly low. Oil starvation is one of the fastest ways to destroy an engine. A quart low is a serious condition that needs immediate attention.
Can I mix different brands of the same viscosity, like two different 5W-40s?
Yes, this is much safer than mixing different viscosities. While it’s always best to stick with the same brand and type to maintain the integrity of the additive package, mixing two API-certified synthetic 5W-40 oils is perfectly acceptable for topping off.
The Bottom Line: Stick to the Spec, but Don’t Panic in a Pinch
So, can you mix 5W-50 and 5W-40? The answer is a qualified “yes”—as a temporary, emergency measure to prevent a much bigger problem.
For the long-term health, performance, and reliability of your engine, the single best practice is to always use the viscosity grade recommended by your vehicle’s manufacturer. It’s the simplest and most effective way to ensure your engine is protected, whether you’re commuting to work, hauling a trailer, or exploring a remote trail.
Keep the right oil on hand, check your levels regularly, and you’ll be prepared for anything the road throws at you. Keep those engines happy and stay safe out there!
- Foamy Oil In Car – Your Complete Guide To Diagnosis, Fixes, And - January 9, 2026
- Motor Oil Foaming – Diagnosis, Prevention, And Ultimate Fixes For - January 9, 2026
- Motorcycle Oil Looks Foamy – Diagnose, Fix, & Prevent Engine Issues - January 9, 2026